Snap
A strand of dry spaghetti, bent until it breaks.
Preparing the strand…
What the picture can say about itself
- twist
- 0°
- grip speed
- 20.0 mm/s
- minimum fragment λ
- 0.0 mm
- first curvature
- waiting
- pieces
- 1
- breaks after first
- waiting
Hold a stick of dry spaghetti by its two ends and bend it until it snaps. It almost never breaks in two. It breaks in three, four, sometimes more, and little bits fly off. It puzzled Richard Feynman, and nobody could say why until 2005.
That year Basile Audoly and Sébastien Neukirch worked it out. When the stick first breaks, each half is suddenly let go. The release sends a burst of bending waves along it. For a moment the waves bend the stick more sharply somewhere else than it was bent before it broke, by up to 43 percent. Taking the load off makes the bend worse, so it breaks again. They filmed it at a thousand frames a second.
In 2018 Ronald Heisser, Vishal Patil, Norbert Stoop, Emmanuel Villermaux and Jörn Dunkel found how to make it break in two. Twist it first, by about 270 degrees, then bend it. The twist adds to the stress, so the strand breaks while it is only gently bent. Then the twist dies away before the bending waves can do any harm. They broke hundreds of 24 cm strands of Barilla no. 3 in a machine with two pivoting grips. They filmed some at up to a million frames a second and measured how stiff and how strong the strands were.
I built my strand from the equations for a thin elastic rod, and I step it a microsecond at a time, the way their simulations did. I took its stiffness, weight and strength from their measurements. I took two more things from them that the equations don't give. Two breaks never come closer together than a few centimetres. They measured how close, and it shrinks the faster you bend. And a crack takes about 10 microseconds to cross the strand.
The twist works. When I bend my strands untwisted, they first break at about as tight a bend as a circle 15 cm across, as theirs did. When I twist them by 270 degrees first, they break in two 95 times in 100, and at 300 degrees every time. The change comes at about 253 degrees. They found about 250. Past 300 degrees some of mine break while I am still twisting them. Theirs gave way to twist alone near 360.
Without the twist, mine break into too many pieces. Theirs broke into three on average when bent slowly. Mine break into five or six. The second break also comes too soon, about 50 microseconds after the first. In theirs it took three times as long. I followed it down. The big pulse Audoly and Neukirch described runs behind a train of smaller, faster waves. A strand bent close to its limit along much of its length breaks on those small early waves. Theirs waited for the big one. I think something in a real strand keeps a small, brief overload from starting a crack. I can't find it in the rod equations, the strength or the crack's 10 microseconds, so I've written to Jörn Dunkel to ask what it is.
The picture copies theirs. Their films are online, and the fastest was shot at 75,000 frames a second: a pale strand against black paper, above a grey table, lit from the left. A camera that fast reads only a small window of its sensor, about 392 by 204 pixels, so the strand is three or four pixels wide and soft at the edges. I draw mine at that size and enlarge it. I measured the grey of the paper, the table and the strand, and the grain, from their frames. The specks that hang between the pieces are drawn, not computed. Audoly and Neukirch saw tiny bits about as wide as the strand thrown off at the breaks, and they show in the film. My rod has no way to make them. The film drops to a four-thousandth of real speed at the first break and comes back up as the pieces land. Once the breaking is over, I let the pieces fly on as rigid bodies.
It isn't a photograph yet. I showed the stills to two readers who had never seen them. Both named the strand as spaghetti, and both still called it a render. Another was shown a frame of theirs beside a frame of mine and picked their film every time. By the end, what gave mine away was mostly the break: my pieces come out nearly equal, at even gaps. That is the same thing I asked Dunkel about.
Drag sideways on the picture to close the grips yourself. Your hand's speed is the grips' speed, and the faster you bend, the more pieces. Set the twist before you bend. Every strand you break goes on the plot above, by its twist and by how sharply it was bent when it first broke. They plotted theirs the same way. Their limit and their line for breaking in two are drawn there too.